old garage renovation

What Materials Are Best For My Garage Door?

The correct garage door can protect your home or company and improve visual appeal. Wood, for example, is a traditional and robust material for garage doors that can give your garage a natural look while providing maximum security. It would help if you had the correct door for your garage because of its impact on the safety and aesthetics of your home. We’ll explain why it’s so important to have the appropriate garage door for your house or company down below.

The Value Of Garage Door Materials

Most people’s first thought when looking to replace their garage door is the material it’s made from. This is because the garage door’s security, visual attractiveness, and longevity are all affected by the materials utilised to construct it. The price of your garage door will also be affected by the material you select. There are cheaper and more expensive garage door materials available on the market. The most expensive material for garage doors is wood, while the least expensive is aluminium.

2023 02

Best Materials For Garage Doors

Steel Garage Doors

Steel doors are common because of their many desirable qualities. They are cheap despite being long-lasting and top-notch. Steel doors can be found in various styles and are often more reasonably priced. Despite being strong, steel is easier on the backside than some of the other options here. High-quality steel holds up well under pressure and prolonged use. Garage doors made of steel are sturdy and long-lasting.

Steel’s susceptibility to rust without an appropriate coating is a potential downside. Over time, the bottom edges of steel garage doors may corrode. The road salt used in areas that get a lot of snow can hasten the appearance of rust. At least twice a year, you should wash your door to eliminate debris and prevent rust.

The R-value of a steel garage door can be improved by installing insulation. The greater the total thermal resistance, as measured by an R-value, the more expensive the material. Steel doors need insulation to improve energy efficiency because metal is a poor insulator.

The benefits of steel garage doors include:

  • Durability
  • Resistant to harm
  • Economical due to the minimal upkeep needed

The drawbacks of steel garage doors include:

  • Reduce the insulation
  • Prone to corrosion and rust
  • The Steel of low grade is vulnerable to damage

Aluminum Garage Doors

Aluminium doors are more modern and can be customised in various stylish ways. Aluminium garage doors can be easily personalised due to the material’s adaptability, allowing for varied window positioning, coatings, and colours.

Lightweight aluminium is susceptible to damage from flying debris, high winds, and hail due to its naturally flimsy construction. If an aluminium door is dented severely, replacing the door may be more cost-effective than attempting repair. The R-value of your garage door can be improved by installing insulation between the aluminium rails.

The benefits of aluminium garage doors are:

  • Unaffected by corrosion
  • Low-maintenance

The drawbacks of aluminium garage doors are:

  • Less durable and susceptible to denting
  • Sensitive to high temperatures

Wood Garage Doors

Wooden garage doors will always stay in style. Wood is a renewable resource and an eco-friendly building material that can easily work into any design scheme. It’s a good idea to invest in a wood door and have it customised so that its style, windows, and paint all match the rest of your home’s facade. Wood doors are the most insulated option when choosing a garage door material.

Wood garage doors cost more initially and require more upkeep than their metal or fibreglass counterparts. Wood garage doors are beautiful and can last for decades with proper maintenance, but they can rot, crack, or distort over time. Because of its susceptibility to damage from temperature swings and humidity, wood doors are best suited to regions with mild winters and summers.

The benefits of wood garage doors include the following:

  • The aesthetic, timeless appearance
  • Better insulation
  • A lot of excellent overlay designs
  • Ability to field-stain

The drawbacks of wood garage doors include:

  • Additional weight
  • Greater manual difficulty
  • Requires routine upkeep
  • Extreme humidity and temperature sensitivity

car park detailing

Wood Composite Garage Doors

Fibreboard is used for the door’s framework in composite garage doors to make them appear wood. Plastic fibre and salvaged wood are the recyclable components used in their construction. The fibreboard in premium composite doors is often denser, and the door’s aesthetic details may seem more authentic in their attempt to mimic a wood door.

Adding insulation to the door’s core can improve a composite door’s thermal efficiency. 

The benefits of composite garage doors are:

  • Aesthetic equivalent to wood
  • Affordable
  • Durable
  • Not susceptible to decay

The drawbacks of composite garage doors are:

  • Can break or chip
  • Maintenance necessary

Fiberglass Garage Doors

The grain texture of fibreglass is meant to resemble that of real wood, making it yet another sort of faux wood. This low-priced material can’t be distorted in size or shape. It’s a smart pick if you inhabit a rainy, humid climate. 

Fibreglass doors can be made with either raised panels or overlays, depending on your taste. This material is perfect for houses in the tropics but is not recommended for use in windy regions or near the ocean. A fibreglass door hit by strong winds makes a unique sound and could be damaged.

The benefits of fiberglass garage doors include:

  • Simple to maintain
  • Aesthetic equivalent to wood
  • Resistant to corrosion and deformation
  • Doesn’t shrink or expand when the temperature changes dramatically.

The drawbacks of fibreglass garage doors include:

  • Could crack with time
  • It is subject to wind damage because of its fragility
  • To repair minor problems, replacement is frequently necessary

Vinyl Garage Doors

Garage doors made of vinyl, a durable synthetic material, are reliable. Doors made of vinyl can be fabricated on steel frames for added durability and insulation to improve thermal performance. Vinyl doors are tough to break and require little upkeep because of this.

Vinyl is a great all-purpose material, but it has flaws because of how vinyl is manufactured; refinishing a garage door can be challenging, if possible. Vinyl is restricted in its colour palette. Once completed, there is no turning back.

The benefits of vinyl garage doors are:

  • Durable
  • Not susceptible to harm
  • Resistant to rust and corrosion
  • Simple to maintain
  • Affordable

The drawbacks of vinyl garage doors are:

  • Only available in the original colour
  • Without additional materials, less insulated

FAQs About Garage Renovation

What Material Should A Garage Door Be?

Steel is a popular garage door material due to its flexibility, durability, and overall value. Steel garage doors are available in endless design options and provide a cheaper, more practical alternative to natural wood. Opt for insulation to strengthen your garage door and boost R-value.

What Type Of Garage Door Is Most Durable?

Steel garage doors are excellent for homeowners who need a durable installation. These garage doors are low-maintenance and economical, and you can often select from various colours. Most installations let you incorporate insulation to enhance R-value. Properly maintained steel doors won’t dent or rust.

What Is The Most Economical Material For A Garage Door?

The most common garage door materials are aluminium, fibreglass, steel, and wood. The cheapest options are steel and aluminium. They’re easy to maintain and work in a variety of climates.

What Is The Safest Type Of Garage Door?

A double-skinned roller garage door provides extra protection against forced entry. Make sure the bottom slat is strong and durable, as this is where most thieves will try to breach your garage door. You can also invest in extra locks and bolts, making it harder for burglars to dislodge the door.

Is Wood Or Steel Garage Door Better?

Due to their lower maintenance and upkeep, steel garage doors have longer lifespans and provide greater durability and stability than wooden doors but don’t provide an upscale look. All in all, steel garage doors Are low maintenance and offer easy upkeep. Fare well in many climates.

Choosing A New Garage Door: Guidelines and Precautions

Prioritise Design Harmony

Choosing a garage door that aligns with the architectural style of your house enhances the overall curb appeal. For instance, if you possess a Craftsman-style bungalow, opting for a garage door with detailed woodwork and divided-light windows would be ideal. In contrast, contemporary residences would benefit from a more minimalist garage door style. The objective is to integrate the garage door seamlessly with the house’s aesthetic rather than making it a focal point of unwanted attention. Various options exist, and bespoke designs can also be commissioned.

Consider Functional Aspects

Different garage door mechanisms serve varying functional needs. While some doors are hinged at the centre and swing outward, others slide sideways, similar to a barn door. Overhead sectional doors, however, are the most prevalent, primarily due to their space-saving features. These doors operate on mounted tracks, unlike swing doors, which require a significant clearance space. Additionally, overhead sectional doors are often more cost-effective to automate, although other door types can also be automated at a higher price point.

Employ Virtual Tools for Decision-Making

Initial visits to dealer showrooms allow hands-on interaction with various types of doors and construction materials. Once you’ve narrowed down your options, utilising virtual visualisation services can be quite insightful. By uploading an image of your house, these services enable you to preview how different garage doors would look, thus aiding quicker and more confident decision-making.

Insulation Is Not to Be Overlooked

In many households, the garage serves as a primary entry point. Thus, an insulated door is a wise investment for these homes. Good insulation not only makes the garage a more comfortable space but also contributes to the home’s overall thermal efficiency. A poorly insulated door may compromise the climate control systems, leading to higher energy consumption. It’s crucial to pay attention to the R-value of the door’s insulation, as a higher value signifies better insulation.

Regular Maintenance Is a Must

The garage door is an integral part of modern residences and demands consistent upkeep. While wood offers undeniable aesthetic appeal, it is susceptible to natural wear and tear. For those seeking low-maintenance alternatives, composite materials—crafted from wood fibres and synthetic resins—offer durability without compromising on visual charm. In coastal regions, steel doors are preferable but require periodic waxing to prevent rusting. Adequate research into maintenance requirements can save you from making an unsustainable choice.

Heed Extreme Weather Conditions

In areas prone to violent storms or high winds, a garage door can be a point of vulnerability. Though completely windproof doors don’t exist, many regions have building codes that require wind-resistant garage doors. The reinforcement is usually internal and doesn’t affect the door’s external appearance, although these doors may be costlier. Consulting local regulations or your garage door provider can offer valuable insights into whether you need such a door.

When selecting a garage door, considerations extend beyond just aesthetics or immediate functional needs. Insulation quality, maintenance commitments, and regional climate factors are equally crucial for a long-lasting and efficient choice.


Your choice of garage door material has a big effect on how safe, beautiful, and long-lasting your home or business is. Wood is a classic, strong material that can look natural and give the most security. How much your garage door costs will also depend on the material you choose. Steel garage doors are the most expensive, but they last long, are hard to break, and save money because they don’t need much maintenance. Steel doors can have a higher R-value if they are insulated, which makes them more expensive.

Aluminium garage doors are more modern and can be made to fit your needs in many different ways. They are not very strong and can be hurt by flying objects, strong winds, and snow. Aluminium doors can be made corrosion-proof and low-maintenance by adding insulation to their R-value.

Wooden garage doors are made from a natural resource and are good for the environment. They can also be made to look like the rest of your house. They offer the best insulation and, with proper care, can last for decades. But over time, they can rot, crack, or change shape.

Composite garage doors are made of recovered materials like plastic fibre and reclaimed wood. The door’s frame is made of fibreboard. Insulation can make them more thermally efficient, giving them the same look as wood and making them cheaper, more lasting, and less likely to rot. But they can break or chip and need to be taken care of regularly.

Fibreglass garage doors are cheap and easy to take care of. They work well in wet, humid areas. They are easy to clean and can be made with raised plates or overlays. But they can crack over time and are easy to damage by wind.

Vinyl garage doors are strong and can be made on steel frames to make them even stronger and better insulated. They are cheap, easy to take care of, and immune to rust and corrosion. But they only come in the original colour and don’t keep you as warm.

When picking a new garage door, think about the style of your house, how it will be used, and how well it will insulate. People like overhead sectional doors because they save room and are easy to operate at a low cost. By letting you look at different choices and compare prices, virtual tools can help you make better decisions.

Homes with a main entrance need better insulation because badly insulated doors can mess up climate control systems and cause more energy to be used. For the door to last as long as possible, it needs to be taken care of regularly. Composite materials, like wood fibres and manmade resins, are strong and look good at the same time. Wind-resistant garage doors may be needed when the weather is very bad, but they may cost more.

Choosing a garage door, you should think about how it looks, how it works, how well it insulates, how much upkeep it will need, and how the weather is in your area.

Content Summary

  • The choice of material for your garage door has a direct impact on its durability, aesthetics, and functionality.
  • Wood is considered the most expensive material for garage doors, whereas aluminium is generally the cheapest.
  • Steel garage doors are popular for their durability and cost-effectiveness.
  • However, steel doors are prone to rust if they lack a proper coating.
  • Insulating a steel door improves its thermal resistance, measured by its R-value.
  • Aluminium garage doors offer modern design options and can be customised easily.
  • Due to its lighter weight, aluminium is more susceptible to wind damage and dents.
  • Wooden garage doors offer natural beauty and better insulation but come with a higher initial cost.
  • Wood doors also require regular maintenance and are sensitive to extreme weather conditions.
  • Composite garage doors mimic the look of wood and offer a balance between affordability and durability.
  • Composite doors are not as susceptible to decay as wooden doors.
  • Fibreglass garage doors are another faux-wood option and are resistant to corrosion and deformation.
  • However, fibreglass doors are more fragile and may crack over time.
  • Vinyl garage doors are durable and easy to maintain but limited in colour options.
  • Choosing a garage door that aligns with your home’s architectural style enhances its kerb appeal.
  • Various types of garage door mechanisms cater to different functional requirements.
  • Overhead sectional doors are most common because they save space and are easier to automate.
  • Virtual tools can help you visualise how different garage doors will look on your home.
  • An insulated garage door is beneficial if your garage serves as a primary entry point to your home.
  • Proper insulation contributes to your home’s overall thermal efficiency.
  • Steel garage doors can corrode over time, especially in areas where road salt is used.
  • Regular maintenance is vital for the longevity of your garage door, regardless of the material.
  • Steel is a poor natural insulator, thus necessitating additional insulation.
  • Wood garage doors can rot, crack, or warp over time.
  • Composite garage doors are generally denser and look more authentic in their mimicry of wood.
  • Fibreglass garage doors are not ideal for windy or coastal areas due to their fragility.
  • The maintenance requirements for each material vary and should be considered before purchasing.
  • Vinyl garage doors are difficult to refinish, limiting your future design options.
  • A door’s R-value indicates its insulating efficiency; the higher the value, the better.
  • Garage doors can be vulnerable during extreme weather conditions such as storms or high winds.
  • Wind-resistant garage doors may be mandated by building codes in areas prone to violent storms.
  • Reinforcements in wind-resistant doors are usually internal and not visible from the outside.
  • However, wind-resistant doors are generally more expensive than standard garage doors.
  • Consider the impact of your garage door on the energy consumption of your home’s climate control system.
  • Vinyl doors can be made more durable and better insulated when fabricated on steel frames.
  • Steel doors offer a variety of styles and are generally more affordable than other materials.
  • Aluminium doors are adaptable and can be customised with various window positions, coatings, and colours.
  • Wooden doors are best suited to climates with mild winters and summers due to their sensitivity to extreme temperatures.
  • Composite doors offer an aesthetically pleasing alternative to wood but can break or chip over time.
  • Fibreglass doors offer an aesthetic similarity to wood and are ideal for humid climates.
  • Vinyl doors are resistant to rust and corrosion.
  • A garage door’s material affects its price, making it an important factor to consider in your budget.
  • Dealer showrooms offer the opportunity to touch and see various garage door materials and styles.
  • Consider the regular upkeep required when choosing a garage door material.
  • Coastal areas may require additional maintenance for steel garage doors to prevent rusting.
  • The colour palette for vinyl garage doors is limited and cannot be changed after installation.
  • Wood garage doors can be field-stained for a unique look.
  • Local regulations and building codes may necessitate specific types of garage doors, especially in storm-prone areas.
  • Insulated doors reduce the strain on your home’s climate control system, leading to energy savings.
  • When selecting a garage door, both immediate functional needs and long-term considerations like climate and maintenance should be taken into account.
Scroll to Top